Casey graduated from St. Andrews University in Laurinburg, North Carolina, in 2012 with a BA in business administration, after which she interned at a small equine practice and took a greater interest in veterinary medicine. In 2014, she graduated from Sanford-Brown College, in Tysons Corner, Virginia, with an AAS in veterinary technology as well as becoming a licensed veterinary technician.

She then spent time at a local university equine hospital administering emergency and elective anesthesia as well as performing specialized diagnostic imaging before becoming a small animal radiation anesthetist and ER technician. Casey joined Piedmont Equine in the spring of 2019 and was reintroduced to equine anesthesia and nursing.

Casey lives with her husband on a farm in Northern Virginia and enjoys spending her spare time with her three horses and showing in dressage and combined training competitions.